Top 10 Change Management Models: A Comprehensive Guide

Change is an inherent part of any organization, and managing it effectively is essential for success. Change management is the process of planning, implementing, and monitoring changes in a structured and systematic way to ensure that they are successful and achieve the desired outcomes. There are several different change management models that organizations can use to guide their change management efforts. These models provide a framework for understanding the change process and how to approach it in a way that maximizes the chances of success.

In this article, we will look at the top 10 change management models and how they can be applied in real-world situations.

In This Article – Change management models

• Introduction to Change Management Models
• The ADKAR Model
• The Kotter Model
• The Lewin Model
• The Prosci ADKAR Model
• The McKinsey 7-S Model
• The Deming Cycle
• The Bridges Transition Model
• The Kanban Method
• The Lean Change Management Model
• Comparison of the Top 10 Change Management Models
• Choosing the Right Change Management Model for Your Organization
• Conclusion

Previous Articles

• Change Management in Health and Social Care – Types, Models, Principles and Steps
• Self-improvement books – why you must read them
• Information Overload: How to Save Time & Energy
• CQC Inspection – A Quick Guide to “Outstanding” Rating
• CQC Standards and CQC KLOE – A Quick Guide
• Quality Improvement Tools in Health & Social Care

The ADKAR Model

The ADKAR model is a change management model developed by Prosci, a research and consulting firm specializing in change management. It is a holistic, individual-focused model that is designed to help organizations and individuals manage change effectively.

The ADKAR model stands for Awareness, Desire, Knowledge, Ability, and Reinforcement. These five elements represent the key stages of the change process. They are essential for successfully implementing and sustaining change.

Awareness: The first step in the ADKAR model is to create awareness of the need for change. This involves understanding the business case for change and the benefits it will bring.

Desire: The next step is to create a desire for change. This involves building support for the change and helping people to see the value it will bring.

Knowledge: Once people are aware of the need for change and desire it, they need to have the knowledge and skills to implement it. This involves providing training and resources to help people understand what they need to do to support the change.

Ability: The fourth step is to help people develop the ability to implement the change. This involves providing the tools, resources, and support they need to successfully implement the change.

Reinforcement: The final step is to reinforce the change and ensure it becomes a permanent part of the organization. This involves continuing to support the change and addressing any challenges that arise.

The Kotter Model

The Kotter model is a change management model developed by John Kotter, a professor at the Harvard Business School. It is an eight-step process that is designed to help organizations implement change effectively.

The eight steps of the Kotter model are:

1. Establish a sense of urgency: This involves creating a sense of urgency around the need for change.
2. Form a coalition: The next step is to build a coalition of people who will lead and support the change.
3. Create a vision: The third step is to create a clear and compelling vision of the future state.
4. Communicate the vision: The fourth step is to communicate the vision to all stakeholders.
5. Empower others to act on the vision: This will also help remove any barriers to change.
6. Create short-term wins: The sixth step is to create short-term wins to build momentum for the change.
7. Consolidate gains and produce more change: Use them to drive further change.
8. Anchor new approaches in the company’s culture: The final step is to anchor the new approaches in the company’s culture. This will ensure they become a permanent part of the organization.

The Lewin Model

The Lewin Model, also known as the Change Management Model, is a three-step process developed by social psychologist Kurt Lewin in the 1940s. It is a simple and easy-to-understand framework for understanding and managing change in organizations.

The three steps of the Lewin Model are:

Unfreeze:

The first step in the Lewin Model is to “unfreeze” the current state of the organization. This involves creating a sense of urgency around the need for change and helping people understand the benefits of the proposed changes. It also involves overcoming resistance to change by addressing any concerns or fears that people may have.

Change:

The second step is to implement the changes that have been proposed. This involves planning the changes and putting the necessary processes and systems in place to support them. It also involves providing training and support to help people adapt to the changes.

Refreeze:

The final step is to “refreeze” the new state of the organization. This involves reinforcing the changes and making them a permanent part of the organization’s culture. It also involves celebrating the successes of the change process and recognizing the contributions of those who were involved.

One of the main strengths of the Lewin Model is its simplicity. It provides a clear and easy-to-follow process for managing change in organizations, which makes it accessible to a wide range of people. It is also highly adaptable, as it can be used in a variety of different contexts and situations.

However, the Lewin Model has some limitations. It is a linear model, which means it assumes that change follows a predictable and linear path. This may not always be the case in real-world situations, where change can be complex and unpredictable. Additionally, the Lewin Model does not take into account the emotional and psychological aspects of change, which can have a significant impact on how people respond to and adapt to change.

Despite these limitations, the Lewin Model is still widely used in organizations around the world and is a valuable tool for understanding and managing change.

The Prosci ADKAR Model

The Prosci ADKAR Model is a change management model developed by Prosci, a research and consulting firm specializing in change management. It is a holistic, individual-focused model that is designed to help organizations and individuals manage change effectively.

The Prosci ADKAR Model stands for Awareness, Desire, Knowledge, Ability, and Reinforcement. These five elements represent the key stages of the change process, and they are essential for successfully implementing and sustaining change.

Awareness:

The first step in the ADKAR model is to create awareness of the need for change. This involves understanding the business case for change and the benefits it will bring. It also involves identifying and addressing any potential challenges or concerns that people may have about the change.

Desire:

The next step is to create desire for the change. This involves building support for the change and helping people to see the value it will bring. It also involves addressing any resistance to change and helping people understand how the change will benefit them personally.

Knowledge:

Once people are aware of the need for change and desire it, they need to have the knowledge and skills to implement it. This involves providing training and resources to help people understand what they need to do to support the change. It also involves helping people understand how the change will impact their work and how they can contribute to its success.

Ability:

The fourth step is to help people develop the ability to implement the change. This involves providing the tools, resources, and support they need to successfully implement the change. It also involves helping people develop the skills and knowledge they need to adapt to the changes.

Reinforcement:

The final step is to reinforce the change and ensure it becomes a permanent part of the organization. This involves continuing to support the change and addressing any challenges that arise. It also involves celebrating the successes of the change process and recognizing the contributions of those who were involved.

One of the main strengths of the Prosci ADKAR Model is its focus on the individual. It recognizes that change is a personal process, and that each person will go through the stages of change in their own way. This makes it a more flexible and adaptable model than some of the other change management models.

However, the Prosci ADKAR Model does have some limitations. It assumes that all people go through the same stages of change in the same order, which may not always be the case. It also assumes that change is a linear process, which may not always be true in real-world situations. Despite these limitations, the Prosci ADKAR Model is still widely used in organizations around the world and is a valuable tool for managing change.

The McKinsey 7-S Model

The McKinsey 7-S Model is a change management model developed by McKinsey & Company, a global management consulting firm. It is a holistic model that focuses on the alignment of seven key elements within an organization: strategy, structure, systems, shared values, style, staff, and skills.

• Strategy: The first element of the McKinsey 7-S Model is strategy. This refers to the long-term plans and goals of the organization, and how they will be achieved.
• Structure: The second element is structure, which refers to the way the organization is organized and how work is divided and coordinated.
• Systems: The third element is systems, which includes the processes and procedures that the organization uses to get work done.
• Shared values: The fourth element is shared values, which refers to the values, beliefs, and culture of the organization.
• Style: The fifth element is style, which refers to the leadership style of the organization and how decisions are made.
• Staff: The sixth element is staff, which refers to the people who work in the organization and their skills and capabilities.
• Skills: The final element is skills, which refers to the technical and functional skills that the organization needs to achieve its goals.

The McKinsey 7-S Model is based on the idea that these seven elements are interconnected and that they need to be aligned in order for an organization to be successful. If any of these elements are misaligned, it can lead to problems and hinder the organization’s ability to achieve its goals.

The Deming Cycle

The Deming Cycle, also known as the PDCA (Plan-Do-Check-Act) Cycle, is a continuous improvement model developed by W. Edwards Deming, a pioneer in the field of quality management. It is a four-step process that helps organizations continuously improve their processes and products.

1. Plan:

The first step in the Deming Cycle is to plan the changes that need to be made. This involves identifying the problem or opportunity, gathering data and analyzing it to determine the root cause, and developing a plan to address the issue.

2. Do:

The second step is to implement the changes that have been planned. This involves putting the plan into action and testing it to see how it works in practice.

3. Check:

The third step is to check the results of the changes and see if they have had the desired impact. This involves collecting data and analyzing it to determine if the changes have had the desired effect.

4. Act:

The final step is to act on the results of the changes and make any necessary adjustments. This may involve continuing with the changes if they have been successful, or adjusting the plan if the changes have not had the desired impact.

The Deming Cycle is a continuous process, which means that organizations should be constantly looking for ways to improve their processes and products. It is a simple and effective model that can be applied to a wide range of situations and industries.

One of the main strengths of the Deming Cycle is its focus on continuous improvement. It encourages organizations to constantly strive for better results and to never be satisfied with the status quo. It is also a flexible model that can be adapted to fit the needs of different organizations and industries.

However, the Deming Cycle does have some limitations. It assumes that the root cause of a problem can be identified and addressed, which may not always be the case in complex situations. It also assumes that the changes that are implemented will have the desired impact, which may not always be true. Despite these limitations, the Deming Cycle is still widely used and is a valuable tool for continuous improvement.

The Bridges Transition Model

The Bridges Transition Model is a change management model developed by William Bridges, a consultant and author specializing in change management. It is a three-stage process that helps individuals and organizations navigate the emotional and psychological aspects of change.

Endings:

The first stage of the Bridges Transition Model is endings. This stage involves letting go of the old way of doing things and accepting that change is happening. It can be a difficult and emotional stage, as people may feel a sense of loss or grief for the things that are changing.

The Neutral Zone:

The second stage is the neutral zone. This is a period of uncertainty and ambiguity, as people are in the process of adapting to the new changes. It can be a stressful and disorienting stage, as people may not know what to expect or how to navigate the new situation.

New Beginnings:

The final stage is new beginnings, where people have adapted to the changes and are able to move forward with a new sense of purpose and direction.

The Bridges Transition Model is based on the idea that change is a process, and that people go through distinct stages as they navigate the emotional and psychological aspects of change. It is a holistic model that takes into account the human side of change and helps people understand and manage their emotions during times of transition.

One of the main strengths of the Bridges Transition Model is its focus on the emotional and psychological aspects of change. It recognizes that change can be difficult and that people may need support and guidance to navigate the process. It is also a flexible model that can be adapted to fit the needs of different organizations and situations.

However, the Bridges Transition Model does have some limitations. It assumes that people go through the same stages of change in the same order, which may not always be the case. It also assumes that people will eventually reach the “new beginnings” stage, which may not always be true. Despite these limitations, the Bridges Transition Model is still widely used and is a valuable tool for managing change.

The Kanban Method

The Kanban Method is a change management model and process improvement approach developed by Toyota, a Japanese automobile manufacturer. It is a visual system that helps organizations manage and improve their workflows by using cards, boards, and other visual tools to represent the flow of work.

The Kanban Method is based on the principles of lean manufacturing. It emphasizes the importance of minimizing waste and maximizing efficiency. It is a flexible model that can be adapted to fit the needs of different organizations and industries.

Main components of the Kanban Method:

• Kanban board: The Kanban board is a visual tool that represents the flow of work in an organization. It is divided into columns that represent the different stages of the workflow. Cards are used to represent individual tasks or items of work.
• Work-in-progress (WIP) limits: WIP limits are used to control the amount of work that is in progress at any given time. This helps to prevent overload and ensure that work is flowing smoothly through the process.
• Pull system: The Kanban Method uses a pull system, which means that work is only started when it is needed. This helps to prevent overproduction and waste.
• Continuous improvement: The Kanban Method emphasizes the importance of continuous improvement. It also encourages organizations to constantly look for ways to optimize their workflows and processes.

The Kanban Method is a simple and effective model that can be used to improve workflows and increase efficiency in a wide range of organizations and industries. It is a flexible model that can be adapted to fit the needs of different organizations and is easy to implement.

However, the Kanban Method does have some limitations. It assumes that the workflow is stable and that the process steps are clear, which may not always be the case in complex or rapidly changing environments. It also assumes that the visual representation of the workflow is accurate and up to date, which may not always be true. Despite these limitations, the Kanban Method is still widely used and is a valuable tool for process improvement.

The Lean Change Management Model

The Lean Change Management Model is a process improvement and change management model based on the principles of lean manufacturing. It is a simple and effective model that helps organizations continuously improve their processes and products by eliminating waste and increasing efficiency.

Main components of the Lean Change Management Model:

• Identify value: The first step in the Lean Change Management Model is to identify the value that the change will bring to the organization. This involves understanding the business case for change and the benefits it will bring.
• Map the value stream: The second step is to map the value stream, which involves understanding the current state of the process and identifying the steps that add value and those that do not.
• Create flow: The third step is to create flow by eliminating waste and streamlining the process. This may involve simplifying the process, reducing lead times, and improving the flow of information.
• Establish pull: The fourth step is to establish pull by implementing a pull system, which means that work is only started when it is needed. This helps to prevent overproduction and waste.
• Seek perfection: The final step is to seek perfection by continuously improving the process and looking for ways to optimize it.

The Lean Change Management Model is a simple and effective model that can be used to improve processes and increase efficiency in a wide range of organizations and industries. It is a flexible model that can be adapted to fit the needs of different organizations and is easy to implement.

However, the Lean Change Management Model does have some limitations. It assumes that the value stream is stable and that the process steps are clear, which may not always be the case in complex or rapidly changing environments. It also assumes that the changes that are implemented will have the desired impact, which may not always be true. Despite these limitations, the Lean Change Management Model is still widely used and is a valuable tool for process improvement and change management.

Comparison of the Top 10 Change Management Models

When it comes to change management, there are many different models and approaches to choose from. Some of the most popular change management models include the ADKAR Model, the Kotter Model, the Lewin Model, the Prosci ADKAR Model, the McKinsey 7-S Model, the Deming Cycle, the Bridges Transition Model, the Kanban Method, the Lean Change Management Model, and more.

One way to compare these change management models is to look at their key features and characteristics.

Examples:

The ADKAR Model is a holistic, individual-focused model that helps organizations and individuals manage change effectively. It focuses on the five key stages of change: Awareness, Desire, Knowledge, Ability, and Reinforcement.

The Kotter Model is a eight-step process that helps organizations implement change effectively. It focuses on creating a sense of urgency, building a coalition, developing a vision, communicating the vision, empowering others to act on the vision, creating short-term wins, consolidating gains, and anchoring the new approaches in the organization’s culture.

The Lewin Model is a three-step process that helps organizations manage change effectively. It focuses on unfreezing the current state, implementing the changes, and refreezing the new state.

The Prosci ADKAR Model is similar to the ADKAR Model, but it is more focused on the individual and their personal journey through change. It focuses on the five key stages of change: Awareness, Desire, Knowledge, Ability, and Reinforcement.

The McKinsey 7-S Model is a holistic model that focuses on the alignment of seven key elements within an organization: strategy, structure, systems, shared values, style, staff, and skills.

More examples:

The Deming Cycle, also known as the PDCA (Plan-Do-Check-Act) Cycle, is a continuous improvement model that helps organizations improve their processes and products. It is a four-step process that involves planning the changes, implementing the changes, checking the results, and acting on the results.

The Bridges Transition Model is a three-stage process that helps individuals and organizations navigate the emotional and psychological aspects of change. It focuses on endings, the neutral zone, and new beginnings.

The Kanban Method is a process improvement and change management model that helps organizations manage and improve their workflows using visual tools and a pull system.

The Lean Change Management Model is a process improvement and change management model based on the principles of lean manufacturing. It helps organizations continuously improve their processes and products by eliminating waste and increasing efficiency.

When choosing a change management model, it is important to consider the specific needs and goals of the organization and the context in which the change is occurring. No one model will be perfect for every situation, and it may be necessary to use a combination of different models or approaches to achieving the desired goals.

Choosing the Right Change Management Model for Your Organization

Choosing the right change management model for your organization is an important decision that can have a significant impact on the success of your change initiatives. There are many different change management models to choose from, and it can be challenging to determine which one is the best fit for your organization.

Important factors when choosing a change management model

Here are some factors to consider when choosing the right change management model for your organization

1. The nature of the change:

Different change management models are better suited to different types of changes. For example, some models are more effective at managing small, incremental changes, while others are better suited to managing large-scale, transformational changes. Consider the nature of the change you are trying to implement and choose a model that is appropriate for that type of change.

2. The size and complexity of the organization

Larger, more complex organizations may require more comprehensive change management models, while smaller organizations may be able to use simpler models. Consider the size and complexity of your organization when choosing a change management model.

3. The culture of the organization

The culture of the organization can have a significant impact on the success of change initiatives. Some change management models are more suitable for organizations with a more traditional, hierarchical culture, while others are better suited to more flexible, agile cultures. Consider the culture of your organization and choose a model that is a good fit.

4. The resources available

Different change management models require different levels of resources and support. Consider the resources that are available to you. Then, choose a model that can be implemented with your resources.

5. The goals and objectives of the change

The goals and objectives of the change should be a key consideration when choosing a change management model. Choose a model that is designed to achieve the specific goals and objectives of your change initiative.

Ultimately, the right change management model for your organization will depend on a variety of factors, including the nature of the change, the size and complexity of the organization

Conclusion – Change Management Models

In conclusion, change management models are an important tool for organizations looking to implement and manage change effectively. There are many different change management models to choose from, each with its own unique features and characteristics. Some of the most popular change management models include the ADKAR Model and the Kotter Model. Others are the Lewin Model, the Prosci ADKAR Model, the McKinsey 7-S Model, the Deming Cycle, the Bridges Transition Model, the Kanban Method, and the Lean Change Management Model.

When choosing a change management model, it is important to consider certain factors. These include the specific needs and goals of the organization and the nature of the change. Other factors are the size and complexity of the organization, the culture of the organization, and the resources that are available. No one model will be perfect for every situation. Thus, it may be necessary to use a combination of different models or approaches to achieve the desired outcomes.

Ultimately, the success of a change management model will depend on its ability to effectively manage the emotional and psychological aspects of change, align the various elements of the organization, and achieve the desired outcomes. By carefully considering the options and choosing the right change management model for your organization, you can increase the chances of success and improve the overall effectiveness of your change initiatives.